Northstar Radar/Laser Detector Field Test.

Above: Northstar Unit
Also in Matt Black with Titanium Effect Buttons
This new radar detector is very simple in use, Power
it up and all 5 bands come on, you can't turn off any of the bands.
It is one problem area as far as I am concerned as we don't use
some of the bands it has in the UK and the X band is the biggest
problem in my eyes as it causes the most false alarms. Selectable
bands on radar detectors are very important.
4 buttons grace the top of the unit, Power, Test,
Scan and C/H (City or Highway). The POWER button is simple, press
it and the unit turns on or off. The TEST button runs the unit
through a simple test mode and demonstrates the various alarm
modes. The SCAN button gives you a knight rider look, the LED's
sequential light on and off from side to side, it does nothing
to the unit apart from make it look flash or annoying which ever
way you decide to look at it. The C/H Button is more important,
to reduce false alarms around town you are better off in the City
mode, on longer open stretches of roads then you must use the
Highway setting as this gives the best range. One odd thing I
found when going into City Mode the volume dropped. On the side
is the power connector and the volume dial.
The warnings are via LED's and Audio. Both do the
job well enough but you get no signal strength meter on this unit.
The Audio Chirp gets faster as you get closer to the Gatso.
Mounting the unit via the Visor clip or the dash
Velcro was a problem for me as my dash is lower than the windscreen
base and the visor is higher than the top of the screen, Gendan
are addressing this by making the more traditional windscreen
sucker mount that should be out soon, (check with Gendan for availability),
so I had to raise the unit for my tests.
Looks are odd as far as I am concerned, gone is
the traditional black unit, they have gone for black and Walnut
effect, I feel it makes the unit look a bit odd and I don't really
like it but wood effect in cars is not to my taste.
The power lead is more than long enough and the
user guide is very good even covering what it will and won't detect.
Over all it is not bad for £120 The real test is does it
work?
So what tests did we do?
I did the usual tests on this unit
and got odd results, the times shown are the best I got. When
I refer to odd results this is what I mean. I did a run round
the North Circular road in London, no not the full length but
from the A10 to the M4. The unit did false alarm but not by much,
Gatso warnings were very good at times but at other times I was
almost on top of the Gatso, I did a drive by on some Gatso's using
the Valentine One to get a signal reading to make sure the gatso's
were on full power most were.
The most important one is the Gatso
Test. We have a section of road that we use for all Gatso tests,
it has one of the lowest radar scatter fields making it more of
a challenge to Radar Detectors it also allows us to do the national
speed limit if we want to. All the Radar detectors are tested
in the same vehicles and in the same position on the windscreen.
The Northstar was subjected to three
passes using a stopwatch to time the unit from the first beep
to the point of passing the Gatso to establish an average warning
time . Speed was 50mph. Please note warning times can vary subject
to conditions.
Times for the Gatso Test. Roadside FIP
Approaching Back of Gatso |
Approaching Face of Gatso. |
|
|
Times for the Gatso Test. M25 Gantry Gatso.
Important Note: The Gatso Used was a
solo Gantry Gatso on the M25 Motorway. Speed was 80mph
No other Gatso was working within 2 miles, this is important
since another Gatso near the area can effect the results in
a major way since they are mounted so high.
Approaching Back of Gatso |
Approaching Face of Gatso. |
|
|
Laser Gun Test.
The Laser gun was used in two ways, the first
test was directly at the car with the detector in it, although
the detector worked and was instant on alarm, if the officer
used the first reading you were in trouble. However they often
take a few readings so you may have a chance to slow. The
second test was to have two cars in front and the operator
target the first car and see if there was enough scatter for
the third car to get an alarm, it was not a problem for the
Northstar we had an alarm in all three runs.
In our opinion you could get a warning or you
could get nicked when it come to the Laser alert mode.
K-Band Radar Gun.
It picked up well at about 1 mile so it would
give you a good warning if the police were targeting other cars
in front of you. Most radar guns are instant on as with Laser
so if they target you directly you won't have time to slow,
but that would be the same for any radar detector.
False Alarm Test.
False alarms are not too good,
as we could not turn off X-Band we got quite a few false alarms
around built up areas.
Can we recommend it? Yes.
This is a low cost unit, offering quite a
good range, at sensible speeds
if you are using a GPS based system and want to know if the
Gatso is working then this could be a good option.
False alarms are higher than units where non UK bands can be
turned off but this
unit is £115 so what more do you want,
if you don't want to spend £200+ for a radar detector
then this may be the one to get.
Try to get it on a 14 day approval, you may have to talk them
into that as
they don't offer it and see what you think.
What do we
like. |
What don't
we like. |
- Price
- Clear Sounds
- Instructions
|
- No user selectable frequencies
- Poor mounting
- No windscreen mount
(They are working on that though)
- False alarms
- Looks, the wood effect.
|
Review: 19th Jan 2002
Important: Results shown are the findings of this site, you
may get different results in your own vehicle.
|